Hannibal by Rail
 

It is well accepted that the HP42s were built along the lines of a railway carriage in layout and furnishing. Here was a brief moment when Hannibal took to the rails! 

17 November 1932  Hannibal was caught by strong winds at the old RAF auxiliary airfield south of Semakh at the southern end of Lake Tiberias, (on the Sea of Galilee).  Imperial Airways had adopted this airfield in late 1931 as a means of speeding their Europe to India service. Conveniently located next to the Lake, passengers could be transferred from the Short Kent flying boats arriving from Greece. 

  The airliners would be secured to concrete blocks to prevent them being moved by the occasional wind gusts known to occur at this location.  The event that threatened to ruin Imperial Airways greatest achievement, delivered only the year before, for service to Karachi or Cape Town from Cairo seems to have been suppressed in the press. Very few direct mentions of the event are to be found. However, one lost sentence in a book suggested more. It relates how the airliner was dismantled and shipped to Cairo to be rebuilt.  Newspapers are vaguer.

  “The experimental service between Ramleh (Cairo) and Baghdad and between Baghdad and Galilee was discontinued in November, 1932.” (1)  

  The air route from England to India has been changed. No longer will the airplanes alight near the Sea of Galilee. The air port of the Imperial Airways has been removed to Ramleh since the Galilee territory is visited by squalls so frequent and violent that even the pegging of the airplanes has proved futile. (5)

 

“Galilee still has a reputation for sudden tempests during the night and early-morning, when strong winds will rise suddenly from one quarter and within a few minutes be blowing from the opposite direction. These gusts have driven the big liners of Imperial Airways from the Galilee district, which was a night stopping place on the London-India air route.  The practice has been to peg down the liners in the open, but the sudden violent gusts have proved too much for the 'planes on the ground. If the winds could be expected from one quarter only the machines could be left in safety, but they could not be tethered afresh to meet each change of direction of the wind. Flying-boats which alight on the sea can ride out the storms, for they swing at their moorings head-on to the wind. Owing to the risk of the big land 'planes being torn from their moorings and damaged in Galilee it has been decided to make Ramleh the port of call for travellers” (8)

  

“ Imperial Airways used to have a night stopping-place In the Galilee district for their liners to India. The liners were pegged down on the landing ground, but it was found that the sudden storms would tear them from even the strongest moorings. “ (4) 

 

A 1949 review of the HP42’s service records, - “One was blown upside down in Galilee”. (2)(3)

In Grants ‘Syrian Desert ‘(7)
They had not reckoned on atmospheric conditions peculiar to the Jordan Valley.  Suddenly variable winds, of astonishing velocity, made the place exceedingly unpopular with pilots.  Finally, one night one of the “Hannibals” was literally blown to bits at its moorings—all except the fuselage. The huge air-liner was moored so firmly to concrete ground blocks that when there was a sudden change in the direction of the wind, succeeded by an eighty-mile-an-hour gale, something had to give: the wings broke into countless pieces, and the fabric blew into ribbons.
 

In the “Log of the Astrea” published in 1933, Hudson Fysh the Managing Director of Q.A.N.T.A.S. describes flying in the “Hannibal’ in July 1933. The earliest (9) mention of the airframe in service after November 1932 appears in journals in late January, early February 1933.  Whether this was a mention of the ‘Hannibal’ or the HP42 class name for promotional reasons remains unclear.

How badly damaged was Hannibal in this incident?  What does it take to retrieve an airliner from remote Palestine in secret and rebuild it to service condition?  

  In 2018 correspondence it is revealed. 

    Researchers (10) have uncovered photographs of the hull of an HP42 aboard Palestine Railways flat cars and the interchange from the Hedjaz Railway 1.05m gauge to standard gauge at Haifa. Why these images were taken, as an enthusiast’s record, or for the airline is not apparent but they were kept private until presented to the Israel State Archives where they are recorded as from ‘1933-1943’ (6) (This may cause some alarm as it might be taken that the images are from after 1940, and 1000 miles away!).

    Knowledge of the damage suffered at Semakh explains the images more sensibly.  Semakh Railway station, (site of a short but severe Great War battle) is only a very short distance from the landing ground.  With the fuselage built to reasonable size it and the damaged wings packed in crates with the great tyres as padding could be loaded for shipment.  The images also show another aircraft (fig.5 Presuming the DH50 was also damaged at Semakh in November 1932) in transit. That aircraft is recorded as being scrapped in 1933. (13)

 

Figure 1  HP42 fuselage is lifted from Hedjaz Railway flat cars. The tyres and undercarriage
 leg lie in place for the journey. The ‘Giant airliner’ can be seen as comparatively small,
even to narrow gauge railway carriages. (6)

 

Figure 2  With the name and airline markings painted out 'Hannibal’ is brought to sit with
the uncovered frame of the tail cone with the vertical rear wheel post bearings prominent
on the waiting flat car. (6)


Figure 3 Attached to the HR flat car the fuselage rides ahead of the main wheels and tailcone. (6)


 

Figure 4 The crates marked IAL with components
of the wrecked wings aboard two flat cars. (6)

 

Figure 5 DH50 G-EBFP on HR flat car from
the same photo collection. This aircraft
was scrapped in 1933.
(6)(13)

  Had 'Hannibal' suffered the winds of fate in virtually any other location on the Empire Mail route it is doubtful that any hope of rebuilding would have entailed a greater expenditure of capital and resources than found in this event.  Consider Rutbah Wells in the vast plains of 'Irak', a flying workshop of materiel and personel would have to be delivered for rebuild in open territory. At Sharjah it may have been possible to load on a ship for return to Britain. A 13 ton load handled by the railways versus by a team of local tribesmen and their animals?

  Taking ‘Hannibal’ by train, first on narrow gauge to Haifa where it was transhipped to standard gauge, and then on to Cairo and Heliopolis Airport was fortuitous. One stage of the journey was by barge on the Suez Canal. Two railways generally unused by Imperial Airways to further its connections lay in the right place to recover their most famous airliner. Generally airline passengers were transferred to Semakh by car from Haifa or Jerusalem or by launch on the sea of Galilee yet rarely by the parallel rail service.

  In aviation circles the circumstances must have been known but to further the cachet of the Empire mail scheme it was little spoken of in the newspapers and aviation journals in particular. Hannibal was quickly rebuilt at Heliopolis and reappeared in service by February 1933. It operated IE 216 to Karachi on May 5th. (14)  Unlike the rebuild after the Five Oaks emergency landing the option to return the airframe to Handley Page was unlikely. The wings were replaced with new shipped from London to Cairo. It was essential to restore the name to the fleet and the work appears to have been done at Heliopolis. An image of Helena sitting between hangars at Heliopolis suggests the scene.


Handley Page H P 42  Helena at Heliopolis
HP42 Helena sits between the Hangars at Heliopolis c1939. (12)
 

 

  'Hengist' was destroyed in a hangar fire at Karachi 31 May 1937. The others seem to have been blown away or run into ditches or embankments from positions on the ground in the UK. It is interesting that so much damage was done to H.P.42 aircraft by wind! It was because ‘Hannibal’ encountered such strong headwinds between Gwadar and Jask in late February that it returned to become the vehicle for those aboard on 1 March 1940. (11)  

At this time Wikipedia has a story of a pilot abandoning an HP42 over Lakenheath! Really?

   

Ref (1) Aeronautical World News - Volumes 8-10 - Page 14 1932 https://books.google.ca/books?id=9tpboYs76_IC

Ref (2) The Aeroplane - Volume 76 - Page 730 1949 https://books.google.ca/books?id=TXnmAAAAMAAJ

Ref (3) Aeroplane and Commercial Aviation News - Volume 76 - Page 730 1949   

 https://books.google.ca/books?id=BEoPAAAAIAAJ

Ref (4) Townsville Daily Bulletin (Qld. : 1907 - 1954) Wed 4 Feb Page No title

 https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/63555522?searchTerm=Imperial%20%2Bairways%20storm%20%2Bgalilee&searchLimits=l-category=Article|||l-availability=y

Ref (5)  The Walther League Messenger - Volume 41 - Page 685 1932 https://books.google.ca/books?id=xKzTAAAAMAAJ

Ref (6)  Israel State Archives  Private collections-Ilan Polkow    http://www.archives.gov.il/en/archives/#/Archive/0b07170680024752/File/0b07170680be8970

Ref (7) Syrian Desert - Page 291 Grant, - 2013  https://books.google.ca/books?isbn=1136192719

Ref (8) The World's News (Sydney, NSW : 1901 - 1955) Wed 5 Apr 1933 Page 34 STORMY GALILEE

 https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/131482341?searchTerm=Galilee%20imperial%20damage&searchLimits

Ref (9) Barrier Miner (Broken Hill, NSW : 1888 - 1954) Mon 30 Jan 1933 Page 2 NURSERIES IN AIR LINERS  https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/48419452?searchTerm=Hannibal&searchLimits=l-category=Article|||l-decade=193|||l-year=1933|||l-availability=y|||l-month=1#

(10) The researchers are Alon Siton with help from Chen Melling, Hans-Wilhelm Berghoff, and Rabbi Dr. Walter Rothschild, editor of a magazine about Middle East railways – see www.harakevet.com   Refer to Mar 2018 edition.

(11) Email correspondence with editor of Harakevet.

Ref (12)http://113squadron.com/853e6510.jpg

Ref (13) Email correspondence with Vern Goodwin 20190717. Evidence of G-EBFP in service from Mafrak to Semakh on March 23, 1933.

Ref (14)  britishairmailsociety.co.uk › ia › Jun2013.pdf

 

Next | Home | Previous | Links |

Richard Hobby, 2018. ( This page is a collation of information from various sources, please address any concerns about source and accreditation to page author ) 20180207